The right to know where we come from
Who am I? The question in the title of Who Am I? A State Matter is not addressed only to the children stolen in Spain between the end of the Civil War and the democratic era. Its makers, director Mercedes Resino and journalist and producer Esteban Creste, extend it to everyone. Their documentary is a finalist for Best Documentary Feature Film at Films Infest (New York City), which has published a conversation with both of them.
The luggage we carry
Creste keeps returning to a line by Walt Whitman, the one about containing multitudes. He reads it this way: each person carries inside them their ancestors, their culture and the environment they were born into, like luggage on their back. For some it is a source of pride; for others, a source of pain. In every case it shapes their identity.
“When someone steals that luggage from you, you lose your history.”
That is why he believes that whoever takes a newborn from their family, often for political or religious ends, commits a crime against the individual and against humanity as a whole. In the documentary, a psychologist goes as far as placing it, in seriousness, right after torture.
A right for everyone
Both filmmakers quote John Donne and his idea that no man is an island: we are bound to the place, the history and the circumstances into which we are born. From this they draw a conclusion that, in their view, even those who deny what happened under the Franco regime share.
“People need to know where they came from and what happened to their ancestors.”
They ask the State to put in place the procedures and tools so that anyone who has the question can get an answer, and they extend an invitation to the whole of Spanish society.
“Spaniards need to look in the mirror and ask: do I really know my origins?”
Their final hope is that the truth eventually comes to light, as it has with other crimes in history, and that facing trauma is always better than hiding it. The documentary is set to screen on November 21 at the Producers Club in New York, a session still to be confirmed in the festival schedule.